Initially targeted for housing development, the lakefront property was later shelved and changed hands.
The Post-Journal and Observer analyze real estate sales in Chautauqua County, most recently examining transactions from Aug. 22 to 31.
During that period, Lodge at Chautauqua Lake LLC of Lakewood sold 74-78 Water Street, Mayville to Erie Bank of Warren, Pennsylvania for $581,714.
This was the site of a 34-unit, $17 million condominium resort proposed by some members of the Webb family. It was announced that this project will not be implemented in 2022.
The property is for sale. It’s listed for sale online for $995,000. Signs on the property direct you to Cushman & Wakefield Pyramid Brokerage Company.
In a separate sale, Mark and Michelle Twitchell sold 85-89 Main St., Fredonia, to New Erie Holding LLC, Fredonia, for $250,000. Dr. Twichell, DDS, specialized in pediatric dentistry before retiring. Before this building was used as a dental clinic, it was home to Lake Shore Savings Bank.
Currently, 85 West Main Street is advertised as having space for rent. The site also features markings for the first natural gas well in the United States.
In another transaction, 8504 East Forest Ave., Portland, to Lake Erie Hidden Treasures LLC, Ripley, sold for $141,500. The Lake Erie Hidden Treasures website describes it as a “rustic cottage with a hidden beach cove on 2.5 secluded acres.” Enjoy swimming, kayaking, and watching beautiful sunsets over Lake Erie. ”
Including the aforementioned sales, there were 14 sales of $250,000 or more. The remaining top sellers are as follows:
— 2608 Shadyside Road, Mina, sold for $690,000.
— 8 Ames Ave., Chautauqua Institute, Town of Chautauqua, sold for $610,000.
— 19 Ramble Ave., Chautauqua Institute, sold for $581,000.
— 786 Abbey Hill Road in Ellington sold for $565,000.
— 46 Coleman Road, Basti, sold for $380,000.
— 120 Chautauqua Escapes, North Harmony sold for $377,500.
— 4186 Driftwood Road in Ellery sold for $340,201.
— 2427 Lakeside Drive, Basti, sold for $310,000.
— 377 E. Main St., Fredonia, sold for $280,000.
— 147 Longview Avenue in Ellicott sold for $275,000.
— 3216 Hooker Road, Charlotte, sold for $250,000.
— 26 Casabella Drive in Fredonia sold for $250,000.
There were a total of 117 transactions between August 22nd and 31st. Here is the complete list of sales over $1:
August 22nd to 25th
National Mortgage LLC of Coppell, Texas, sold 9 Water Street, Sinclair Building, to Daniel Barker for $30,000.
Marucci Property Management, LLC of Jamestown sold five lots in Falconer to Ideal Industrial Services, LLC of Jamestown for $95,000. Addresses include properties at 20 Cross St. and E. Elmwood Avenue.
Franklin Pagano sold 1360 Rt. 5. Silver Creek Go to Silver Creek Village for $10,000.
Florence Seibert, Judith Westling and Mark Seibert sold 33 Wright Park Avenue, Dunkirk to Arthur Hallett Page V for $191,250.
Bud Osborn sold 18 Arlington Avenue in Jamestown to Annie Brooks for $85,000.
Thomas Whitermore sold 5523 N. Rt. 62 Ellington to Amir Khan for $20,895 and 25 Wilson Place for $8,000.
Michael and Shannon Near sold 711 Park Avenue, Dunkirk to Lynette Soto for $132,500.
Kyle Pfeiffer sold 67 Lester St., Sinclair Building, to Chad and Chelsea Brown for $144,200.
J&G Enterprises WNY, LLC of Fredonia sold 112 S. Zebra St., Dunkirk, to Annet A. Hernandez Sanchez for $95,000.
Louis Lasitano, manager, sold 52 Linwood Avenue, Jamestown, to Thomas Bailey Jr. for $30,000.
Lauryn Reading, Kimberly Reading and Wendy Lee sold 3950 S. Clifford Ave., Ellery to John and Joy Stephens for $199,900.
Stephanie Buccola, Peter Fuller and Julie Pickett sold 130 Hickory St. in Ellicott to David Sundquist for $139,000.
Chautauqua County Land Bank sold 129 Fairview Avenue, Jamestown, to CMG Development, LLC, Jamestown, for $5,000.
Jeffrey Franklin sold 1739 King Road, Hanover, to Daniel Meade for $65,000.
Ryan Cessna sold 145 Lakeview Avenue, Lakewood, to Leanna Luca-Conley for $130,000.
Carly Foti sold 217 E. Pearl St., Falconer to Kathleen Barmore for $19,000.
Betty DeLand sold 8 Harmon Avenue, Brockton, to Jennifer Rosas for $70,695.
Tracy Carlson sold 34 Douglas Place, Jamestown, to James McGee for $97,000.
Linda Yates sold 1176 Hunt Road, Basti, to Wyatt and Alyssa Perry for $98,000.
Daniel Komorowski sold a vacant lot on Summit Avenue in Ellery to Mark and Daniel Hinman for $37,500.
Daniel Pavlock and Olivia Pavlock sold 3216 Hooker Road, Charlotte to Kyle Pfeiffer for $250,000.
Jennifer Miller, Colleen Brunswick, Lisa Valentine and Danielle Brown sold 41 Market St., Dunkirk, to Michael and Paula Stoiber for $191,000.
Douglas Hillerby sold 245 Fulton Street, Jamestown to Jonathan Cairo for $25,000.
Leona and Edmund Elwell sold 1201 Angell Road, Hanover to Nicholas Leone for $185,000.
Stonehill 716, LLC of Lakewood sold 346 Delaware Avenue, Dunkirk to Corne Jones for $89,900.
Richard and Jeanne Anderson sold 46 Coleman Road, Basti, to Tyler and Jeanne Nelson for $380,000.
August 28-31
Richard Fisk and Donna Culver Fisk sold 43 Chestnut St., Westfield, to Lyle Fell Jr. for $185,000.
Nancy Marenga sold 46 Howard St., Jamestown, to Kaylee Brunacini for $91,000.
Christopher Berreth sold 5 Orchard Street in Jamestown to Tiffany Raybould for $500 and 6 Orchard Street for $1,000.
David and Amber Seekings sold 75 East Main Street, Falconer, to Ashley Bobek for $165,000.
Flip Jtown LLC of Asheville sold 4483 W. Fairmount Ave., Basti City to Red State Charlie Capital LLC of Fairfax, Virginia, for $129,000.
Bear Creek Properties LP of Barrie, Ontario, Canada, sold 901 Prendergast Avenue and 115 Crossman Street in Jamestown to Red State Charlie Capital, LLC for $120,000.
Rick Martin sold 218.5 Newland Avenue in Jamestown to Red State Charlie Capital LLC for $80,000.
Thomas and Tammy Bolman sold 418 Falconer St., Jamestown, to Red State Charlie Capital LLC for $100,000.
Jeffrey and Leanne Homza sold 26 Casabella Drive, Fredonia, to Bonnie Burmaster for $250,000.
The trustees of the Jane Currie Revocable Living Trust sold a parcel on Springbrook Road in the Town of Chautauqua to the Town of Chautauqua for $75,000.
Joseph Dome sold 910 Edgewater Drive, Westfield, to Thomas Robson for $40,000.
Richard Simon sold 105 Midgley St., Jamestown, to Christian Peterson for $102,000.
Aaron Leeper sold 803 Harding Ave., Jamestown, to Eliza Fuentes Muñoz for $45,000.
Howard F. Haskin, Howard R. Haskin and Gwendolyn Haskin sold 8504 East Forest Ave., Portland, to Lake Erie Hidden Treasures LLC, Ripley, for $141,500.
Sherwood Potter and Jeanne Lyon Potter sold 10266 Cortright Road, Asheville, Town of Harmony to Mosie Yoder and Bertha Yoder for $12,500.
Mark Twitchell and Michelle Twitchell sold 85-89 Main St., Fredonia, to New Erie Holding LLC of Fredonia for $250,000.
Leary Walker sold 27 West 10th Street, Jamestown to Rene Page for $9,000.
Ashley and Nicholas Dubois sold 15 North Ocelot Street, Dunkirk, to Richard Gardner and Gerald Gary II for $140,000.
William Petko and Rochelle Petko sold a parcel on West Side Hill Road in Ripley to Marvin Troyer for $84,900.
Sarah D’Agostino, Benjamin Yount and Kristin Vogt sold 5270 Lewis Road in Ellery to Heather Schreiner, Samuel Carson and David Vogt Jr. for $42,858.
The Estate of Frank Nelson sold 1244 Austin Hill Road, Frewsburg, Carroll Town, for $80,000.
Cheap Lands Inc., Port St. Lucie, Fla., sold 413 W. Sixth St., Jamestown to Joanna Sevilla for $7,600.
MCLP Asset Company of Dallas, Texas sold 15 East Pearl Street, Falconer to David Brainerd for $113,500.
Greg and Susan Davis sold 786 Abbey Hill Road, Ellington, to Daniel and Olivia Pavlock for $565,000.
Diana Gronquist sold 427 S. Main St., Jamestown, to Tristan Myers for $85,000.
Eugene and Carol Albright sold 147 Longview Avenue in Ellicott to Derek and Brianna Burdick for $275,000.
John Hanlon and Sylvia Hanlon sold property on Berry Street in Fredonia to Brian and Alicia Bongiovanni for $25,000.
Derek Ames sold 222 Hazeltine Avenue, Jamestown, to Maria Ballard for $50,000.
Cascade Funding Mortgage Trust HB4 of Houston, Texas sold 338 South Main Street, Jamestown to Elisandra Torres for $57,475.
Matthew Davis sold 2994 Fluvanna Townline Road, Ellicott, to Brandon Reagle for $90,000.
Celeste Lira sold 2427 Lakeside Drive, Basti to Jonathan and Megan Price for $310,000.
The Lodge at Chautauqua Lake LLC of Lakewood sold 74-78 Water Street, Mayville to Erie Bank of Warren, Pennsylvania, for $581,714.
Duff Land Holdings LLC of Forestville sold 377 E. Main St., Fredonia to Mimi and Stephen Joynt for $280,000.
Paul and Roseann Carlson sold 266 Lake Shore Drive West, Dunkirk, to Darryl and Rebecca Frost for $95,000 and a parcel on West Chestnut Street for $5,000.
Michael and Constance Nemeth sold 120 Chautauqua Escapes, North Harmony, to Jody Tulli and Carl Good for $377,500.
RTV Properties LLC of Williamsville sold 8005 Felton Road, Westfield to Rodney Hauser for $64,890.
Judge Laurie Williams sold 4437 South Hill Road, Ellington, to WNY Partner Holdings Inc., Buffalo, for $52,112.
Anthony and Janet Kapuscinski sold 26 Clinton Avenue, Fredonia, to Bermudez Jose Mesonet and Carmona Maria Rivera for $220,000.
Florence Minton sold 491 South Main Street, Jamestown to Michelle Ford for $65,000.
Paul and Brenda Tabone sold 42 Lambert Avenue, Fredonia, to Thomas Abruzzo for $130,000.
The Chautauqua County Land Bank sold 115 Broadhead Avenue, Jamestown, to Bill Safford and Dave Bemis for $20,000.
Joel Spencer sold 41 Royal Avenue, Jamestown to John Errico and Dean Knight for $155,355.
Merrill Streeter sold 19 Rumble Avenue, Chautauqua Institute, Town of Chautauqua, to Robert Zelin for $581,000.
Ronald Marsh sold 4 Water Street, Hanover, to Michael Rogers for $25,000.
Helen Johnson sold 229 Sugar Grove Road, Basti to Andrew and Carly Lata for $153,000.
The trustees of the Barbara Leight Revocable Living Trust sold the Chautauqua Institute, 8 Ames Avenue, in the Town of Chautauqua, to Jerome and Katherine Chesley for $610,000.
Margaret Smith’s executors sold R7,960. 474, Clymer to Craig Rotunda, $88,000.
Carl and June Kimmich sold 2608 Shadyside Road, Mina, to Dillon and Bethany Stein for $690,000.
Tony Willsen sold 4186 Driftwood Road, Ellery to Donald Chadwick and Sherry Chadwick for $340,201.